Thrift Store Donation Pickup: A Beginner’s Guide

9:05

Most thrift stores rely on donations from members of the community to stock their shelves.

When donations come in regularly, shelves stay full, but when they’re scarce, the sales floor can start to look sparse. This often leads thrift store owners to find ways to increase donations. One effective approach is offering donation pickup from customers’ homes.

When customers have to bring used clothes, electronics, or other items to a donation box or the store, it’s easy for them to procrastinate or forget. Sending drivers to retrieve donations from their homes makes the process simple and stress-free.

In this blog, we’ll cover six strategies to help you set up and manage thrift store donation pickup effectively.

Let’s get started.

Benefits of Offering Thrift Store Donation Pickup

Adding a donation pickup option is helpful for customers and for your thrift store. Here are some of the key benefits.

Boost Donations

If your thrift store has been around for a while, you’ve probably built up a base of frequent donors. These customers make the trip to your store or to a local donation box to drop off items they don’t need anymore. There’s likely another group who wants to donate items, but feels pressed for time. Offering at-home pickup lets you reach this audience and grow your donor pool.

Improve Customer Convenience

Donation pickup requires very little effort from the customer. They simply sign up for a pickup time, gather the items they want to donate, place them in a bag or box, and set them on their porch. This convenient option is a great fit for customers with busy schedules.

Strengthen Customer Loyalty

Not all thrift stores offer a donation pickup option. When customers experience the ease and simplicity of signing up, placing the items on their porch, and having your team pick them up, they’re more likely to donate to your store instead of a competitor. Offering this convenient service also shows customers that you value their time and support, which helps build long-term loyalty.

6 Strategies for Managing Thrift Store Donation Pickup

It may seem simple, but thrift store donation pickup requires several steps of logistical setup. Follow these steps to ensure you’re prepared for the entire process.

1. Create an Easy Sign-Up Experience

For customers, donation pickup is a convenient alternative to bringing items to the shop. You can make this option even easier by creating a simple sign-up process. Create a page on your website where customers can schedule a pickup date and select a time window.

The more information you have about a donation, the more prepared you are. Ask customers to provide their name, address, phone number, the category of items they’re donating, and include a photo so the pickup crew knows what to expect. It’s also a great opportunity to give customers instructions for donations, like putting clothes and small items in bags or boxes.

2. Communicate Clearly With Customers

The donation pickup process goes more smoothly when you communicate clearly with customers. Start by letting them know which items you accept and which you don’t.

Common thrift store items include:

Clothes
Shoes
Kitchenware
Home goods, such as decorations
Furniture
Electronics

Items thrift stores typically don’t accept:

Mattresses
Large appliances, like washers, dryers, or refrigerators
Paint
Weapons and ammunition
Damaged items

Listing clear acceptance guidelines on your website helps make the process smoother for everyone involved. You might need to set size and weight limits so large items don’t take up too much space on your sales floor.

If you show up to pick up and an item doesn’t meet your standards, you can decline it, but be sure to apologize to the customer and suggest an alternative removal method, like a local recycling program.

It’s also a good idea to text the customer to confirm their sign-up, send a reminder when the truck’s en route, and follow up with a thank-you once their donation has been picked up. You can automate this process using a point of sale (POS) system. Sending these messages helps you avoid forgotten or missed appointments and ensure everyone’s on the same page.

3. Use Efficient Routes

The farther your pickup drivers travel, the more fuel they use — and the more it costs your business. That’s why it’s important to plan routes efficiently. Limit donation pickup to a set distance from your thrift store.

Give customers a time window — maybe a few hours — so your team has the flexibility to collect donations in the most convenient order. Careful route planning saves time, cuts fuel costs, and keeps your drivers on schedule.

4. Train Donation Drivers on Safety & Professionalism

Sometimes a customer wants to donate larger items, like couches or dining room tables. In these cases, you may need multiple employees to enter the home and load the item into the pickup vehicle. Remember: Train your drivers in safety and home etiquette for these situations.

First, make sure drivers have the moving equipment they need, including dollies, blankets, straps, and door-jamb protectors. For large items, send two drivers on the trip.

Coach employees to be friendly and courteous, and to take extra care not to cause any property damage. Empower them to decline an item if it doesn’t meet your donation standards.

5. Track KPIs & Improve Continuously

Tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) help you understand how successful donation pickup is for your thrift store.

Try monitoring these key metrics:

Request-to-completion rate: This metric tracks how many pickups you complete successfully without having to decline items or reschedule. If a high percentage of requests can’t be fulfilled, you may need to adjust your operations.
On-time arrival: Strive to always arrive within the customer’s requested time window. If you don’t, apologize and look for ways to improve. You may need to schedule fewer pickups or expand the time window if drivers are consistently running late.
Cost per route: Knowing your costs is essential for assessing whether donation pickup is sustainable for your thrift store. Make sure the value of the donations you’re bringing in outweighs the fuel and labor cost associated with pickups.
Average items per stop: The more items you collect at each stop, the more value you generate. While this metric is in the hands of the customer, tracking it helps you understand how much value each stop contributes overall.
Reschedule rate: When customers reschedule at the last minute, you waste time and money. You can reduce unnecessary trips by asking customers to contact you well in advance if they need to reschedule.

Keep an eye on your metrics to gauge how well donation pickup is working for your thrift store. If the numbers look good, you might consider expanding your efforts.

6. Use a Digital System To Coordinate Pickups

Managing thrift store donation pickup is a multistep process. Rather than handling each step manually, you can use a digital system to lighten the load. Some POS platforms include features that make this easier.

Look for a system that offers customer self-scheduling, driver route assignments, and automated messaging so you can send confirmations, reminders, ETAs, and thank-you notes. Reporting tools are also valuable — POS systems with customizable reports help you track your progress so you can improve over time.

Expertly Manage Thrift Store Donation Pickup With ThriftCart

Donation pickup is a great way to bring more donations into your thrift store. Screening these donations helps you maintain high quality and find the items your shoppers want to buy.

If you aren’t sure how donation pickup works for your thrift store, start small. Offer the option to a limited range of customers near your store and see what kinds of donations you receive. If it’s successful, you can expand the program.

A POS system designed for your industry is the best way to manage donation pickup efficiently. ThriftCart is a cloud-based POS solution built specifically for thrift stores. With our all-in-one system, you can add self-scheduling to your website, automate text and email messages to customers, and generate comprehensive reports. This is in addition to other useful features like payment processing, inventory management, and e-commerce.

At ThriftCart, we offer several different packages so you can choose the features your thrift store needs at a price that fits your budget. Check out our Build and Price tool to find the package that’s right for your business!

Thrift Store Donation Pickup: A Beginner’s Guide